qualia;Is there something I’m missing?

Basically, I’ve talked to quite a lot of people on reddit, mostly on religious debate subs, who will argue that all experience is „just neurons firing“ or „just neurological metadata,“ etc. They don’t seem to be merely claiming that subjective experience can’t exist without a physical body; that much I would understand. I get how within physicalism, consciousness can be seen as emerging from physical processes. But it seems to go deeper than that.

Time and again, when I try to distinguish between sensation and perception, or when I even bring up the word qualia, I find that some people on here are deeply skeptical, or even seem to find the idea laughable. I can’t understand how anybody could reject these concepts unless they were either an automaton or live in a deep state of dissociation. It seems self-evident to me, like „cogito ergo sum.“ I know experience exists, because I have direct evidence of it.

I’ve read Daniel Dennett’s criticism of qualia and honestly I didn’t understand it, it seemed unintuitive and left me wondering if I misunderstand what the word „qualia“ even means. But even if there is some complicated argument you could make for this position, it doesn’t explain the sheer number of redditors I’ve talked to who use phrases like „no you’re just talking about neurons firing“ as though it’s common sense.

Is there something I’m missing?

“Death is nothing at all” by Henry Scott-Holland

05.11.2024

Death is nothing at all. It does not count. I have only slipped away into the next room. Nothing has happened. Everything remains exactly as it was. I am I, and you are you, and the old life that we lived so fondly together is untouched, unchanged. Whatever we were to each other, that we are still. Call me by the old familiar name. Speak of me in the easy way which you always used. Put no [...]

 Grey Heaven Fall from Podolsk, Russia

05.11.2024

I will always be grateful to the god of black metal that gives us the opportunity to discover every day wonderful bands from around the world, like Grey Heaven Fall from Podolsk, Russia, a black metal trio formed in 2006. Black Wisdom is their second album and I feel safe saying that it is a gem. In the music of the Russian band the listener can hear echoes from throughout the history of [...]

—Gilles Deleuze and Seneca

05.11.2024

“The body of the woman is the overwhelming triumph of flesh. The woman is a concrete universal; she is a world, not an externalized world, but under the world, the warm interiority of the world, a compressed internalized world.” —Gilles Deleuze http://christiania.cz/kolaps-systemu-split-w-posledna-minuta / Seneca / . „Withdraw into yourself, as far as you can. Associate with those who [...]

US Election 2024 Global Reaction Italy

Prečo Američania volia prezidenta zakaždým prvý utorok v novembri? Môžu za to Dušičky, zber úrody aj farmárske trhy

06.11.2024 02:30

V roku 2009 jeden kongresman navrhoval termín prezidentských volieb presunúť na prvú sobotu alebo nedeľu v novembri po Dušičkách. Nepochodil však.

New York / US voľby /

ONLINE: Prvé výsledky amerických volieb sú známe. Trump vedie v kľúčovom štáte Georgia

06.11.2024 00:00

Harrisovej štáb sa chystá na možnosť, že sa Trump predčasne označí za víťaza.

novi sad

Pád prístrešku na stanici v Srbsku neprežila aj 20-ročná dolnozemská Slovenka

05.11.2024 23:10

Zahynula spolu so svojím priateľom. Tragédia v Novom Sade si vyžiadala celkovo 14 obetí.

rukojemníci, izrael

Izrael ponúka Hamasu milióny dolárov za prepustenie rukojemníkov

05.11.2024 22:10

Predstaviteľ Hamasu však označil túto ponuku za "frašku" a uviedol, že rukojemníci budú prepustení len na základe dohody, ktorá ukončí vojnu a zruší blokádu Pásma Gazy.

Štatistiky blogu

Počet článkov: 1,203
Celková čítanosť: 268659x
Priemerná čítanosť článkov: 223x

Autor blogu

Kategórie