– Galen Strawson, Closer To Truth, Mysteries Of Free Will, Feb 12, 2018
23. marca 2024 14:10,
Prečítané 21x,
kristian66,
Nezaradené
„I can give you an immaterial soul. I’ll give you indeterminism. It doesn’t matter. What I’m going to say is that is not going to help.
I’m going to say, in the end, what you do flows from the way you are, even in your deepest spiritual characteristics.
You’ve somehow got to get to be responsible for being the way you are. But you can’t… You can’t get back behind yourself in such a way as to be responsible for the kind of person you are.
Whichever way it goes, you’ve got to somehow have chosen it, but you can’t choose it unless you already exist as a creature who has preferences. You can’t get back behind yourself in such a way as to be responsible for the kind of person you are.
There’s a two-word Latin phrase; you can’t be causa sui. You can’t be the cause of yourself.
But you’d somehow have to get to be the cause of yourself to take fundamental ultimate responsibility for yourself and therefore for your actions that flow from the way you are, and therefore we do not have free will. I think you can’t escape that conclusion.“
15.04.2024
Life Hack you should be smart enough to learn & emulate ; 1. Stay silent. Not everything needs to be said. „Silence is better than unnecessary drama.“ 2. If you find someone smarter than you, work with them, don’t compete. Competition is a weakness. 3. The family you create is more important than the family you come from. 4. Your current job doesn’t care about you. [...]
14.04.2024
Derrida považuje svoju gramatológiu za „nástroj kritiky (západnej) metafyziky, pretože táto (gramatológia) siaha až k samým koreňom fonetického písma (phonetic writing), t. j. písma, ktoré (graficky) reprodukuje hlásky slova a tým sa stáva nielen koextenzívnou s metafyzickým myslením, ale priamo jeho primordiálnym predpokla- dom. Derrida je presvedčený, že ‚fonetické [...]
14.04.2024
Derridova ‚dekonštrukcia‘ naráža na očividný paradox: kritika subjektivisticky ponímaného rozumu je možná iba v jeho vlastnom metajazyku a jeho vlastnou argumentáciou. Heidegger hľadal východisko z tohto paradoxu v ezoterickom jazyku svojho diskurzu, ktorého vágnosť ho navyše chránila pred príliš špecifickými námietkami kritikov (Habermas, 2000, s. 185). Derrida tu [...]
Celá debata | RSS tejto debaty